If you had told me when I was in high school that I would spend at about 15 hours a month on an airplane I would have responded that you were crazy. You see, my family are drivers. We need to go somewhere? We pack up the car and we go. 1200 miles? No problem, its barely a days drive.
As an Adobe Trainer I have the opportunity to go all over the country and share Flex with companies that are ready to start building RIA’s in Flex. Beyond that as a ColdFusion conference frequenter I get a full share of airplane time in. But as very few of these opportunities present themselves to me in my area, I do spend a bit of time on planes.
Mostly this is not a problem. I have an iPod and a Nintendo DS. I have a laptop (which I am writing this on now) that when I travel in first class I have enough space to use. Since I don’t travel first class often (today is my second time in my life) I am mostly relegated to use my portable electronics to entertain myself. Its no surprise (everyone says so) that after about an hour of use the iPod ear buds start to hurt. I like the sound these little buds put out, but for a plane ride they just don’t cut it for longevity. Also they do nothing to cut out the background noise of the plane.
To work on solving the background noise dilemma on a recent trip I borrowed a friends Brookstone headphones. These are the mighty large over the ear kind that come with a bundle mid-way on the cord that has a couple batteries and a switch to turn on noise canceling. I put these puppies on and hit the switch. I was amazed as the sounds of the plane slowly faded away. “Wow” I remember thinking. The effect was quite a bit more profound than I had expected. However even as the sound faded away, I started to feel a sharp pain in my head. As I listened to music it built up until halfway through the first song, I thought for sure I should take them off because otherwise I would have to return them to my friend bloody. I decided these brookstone headphones were not for me and put in my iPod buds. The pain from them was slow building and in comparison, it was really more of an ache than a pain.
On a return trip from my last training gig, I sat next to another traveling trainer. As we talked shop and compared tech, he brought out his Bose headphones. Similar to the brookstone headphones in size this headset is often considered the holy grail of listening equipment. I told him the story about the others headphones I had tried and he insisted I give his Bose a feel. I put them over my ears, and could immediately feel the difference in quality over the Brookstone pair. He showed me the switch to turn on the noise canceling and I enabled the feature. Just as soon as the background noise had faded away, the ear-splitting, brain-melting pain began again. As I removed these headphones from my head I realized that I was certainly not meant to own a pair of headphones with active noise canceling.
I assumed that was the end of the road, and decided my iPod ear buds were gonna have to do. But somehow I just wasn’t satisfied with that as the solution. So I asked around a bit and found that although many folks had a headset that they liked, they had been eyeing the Shure family of ear buds as a possible next purchase. So I started to look that route as well. On the Shure.com website they state that they earbuds use “Sound Isolating Technology” and unlike active noise canceling headphones “no artifacts are introduced into your listening experience”. I thought 2 things when I read this. 1. So I jam these in my ears and then they block sound. Huh, might as well just plug my ears. 2. No extra noise artifacts? Maybe this is what caused my headaches with the other headsets. After wrestling with the though of spending $200 on a set of headphones that implement sound isolation by plugin my ears, i finally gave in.
I bought a pair of the e3c headphones at Best Buy for $179 on friday afternoon. I took them back the office with me and while my friends laughed at me for spending that much on ear buds I decided to try them out. As they sat making jokes I readied the buds for my ears. As I carefully inserted them and found a comfortable position, i didn’t really notice any change. Until I looked up and realized that they guys in my office were still talking but I couldn’t hear them AT ALL. I had two guys standing in my office no more that 10 feet from me speaking at a little louder than normal and I couldn’t hear them. It was neat but I didn’t really put much faith in them working in the loud airplane.
Well today that was put to the test. And I was amazed at the results. As i sat on the plane while we took off, I waited till it was ok to start using my ipod. Once the flight attendant gave the ok, I pulled out the new earbuds and proceeded to put them in. The effect was immediate and profound. The noise was completely blocked out and my music was gloriously clear. I didn’t even have to turn the ipod up to half volume to feel like I was rocking out. And the best part? No ear splitting pain in my head! Total sound blocking, glorious music reproduction, and no pain. I think I may have found heaven.
So if you or someone you know is thinking about getting some new headphones I can not recommend the Shure headphones enough. I was skeptical but i am converted now.
Ps. Special Thanks to Dan Short for being the first to turn me on to these buds.